I truly believe there is a great film here. But almost all of its key emotional moments fall so flat it is almost astounding. Rosamund Pike delivers a cringe worthy performance. I seriously cringed during one scene where she screams... To be honest, her performance was the worst thing about this film, and the problem I believe is not the actresses but the director. Almost every actor on screen delivers scenes that should make you feel sorrow but instead makes you question, why is this so unrealistic.

Almost no one is sparred, besides of course Bale, he is fantastic in this film. He somehow manages to keep his character grounded and solid. Also, Jesse Plemons is quickly becoming one of my favorite actors. He has a very small role, but he has such a great presence on screen and delivers a scene wonderfully. The best part of the film is of course the cinematography, truly showcasing America's open lands is never tiring to see, and the cinematographer sets up wide shots that are breathtaking. Lighting is handled just as well. Sets and costumes are flawless.

The other major thing is the writing, if I were to tell you the events that occurred in this film, you would say holy shit that sounds intense, but again the director/Writer Scott Cooper overwrites most of the monologue and dramatic moments. This film was ripe to be quieter and focused. The themes of death, murder, racism are poignant and ready for the taking but most of the time the writing is trying to shove it down your throat via monologue and spoken sentiments.

I guess the last thing I will say is that the beginning of the film perfectly sets the mood for the rest. It's not as sickening as it could or should be... But if you happen to like the first ten minutes of this film. I reckon you might enjoy the rest of it a decent amount like I did.

So, in ending

6/10

It’s a troubled film dealing with troubling material, Bale delivers a great performance and the ideas are fine, but Cooper doesn’t tie this film up well enough or execute it with the justice it deserves.